Response to calls for Assisted Dying law changes after Maurice Gee’s suicide
A call for liberalisation in the End of Life Choice Act is a call to release unstoppable suicide, Voice for Life says.
The Post published an article regarding the death of well known New Zealand author Maurice Gee last month, after he committed suicide in his home in Nelson.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: National medical director calls for brakes on euthanasia expansion
By The Defender. Talks of expanding the eligibility criteria in assisted suicide and euthanasia legislation have been met with strong caution by Royal College of GPs medical director Dr Bryan Betty. The contrast and imbalance of palliative care vs assisted suicide and euthanasia is sizeable and cause for concern, he says.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: Media bias shows balance truly gone
By The Defender. Media coverage of the assisted suicide and euthanasia anniversary last week has made it clear there’s been an unfettering of any tether to balance and fairness on the issue. It’s been a week of “celebration” for the first anniversary of the End of Life Choice Act operating in our country and the media stories by Stuff and NZ Herald have been shocking.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: One year on, NZ's Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia Death Toll
By The Defender. One year on. This week marks an anniversary not to be forgotten; but also not to be celebrated. It is one year since the End of Life Choice Act has been operational in New Zealand. We have lost more than 214 lives to assisted suicide and euthanasia as a result. And tragically, more than 596 people have applied for access to the lethal dose.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: Disabled and terminally ill among first victims of Trevor Mallard, but media refused to tell the story
By Henoch Kloosterboer. With the welcome departure of former Speaker of the House Trevor Mallard, there’s been a lot of talk about the public scandals that have plagued his tenure. There is one very serious incident, however, that you probably aren’t aware of – that #DefendNZ were one of the first victims of Trevor Mallard’s authoritarian excesses at Parliament.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: New reports reinforce the urgent need for amendments to the End of Life Choice Act
By The Defender. It has now been almost ten months since the practice of assisted suicide and euthanasia began in our country, and recently the first official reports were published detailing what has happened in New Zealand over that period. Significant issues identified include a lack of detailed reporting, lack of palliative care uptake, misleading New Zealanders and much more.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: Better supports needed at end of life says traumatised Timaru widow
By The Defender. A recent article investigated what it described as the “mess” of palliative care. Timaru woman, Jackie Goodfellow, whose husband Ron had recently died from terminal lung cancer, had an experience that mirrors many in New Zealand. Supports are simply not accessible.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: The elephant in the room: 51% increase in palliative care capacity needed by 2038
By The Defender. With the number of Kiwis needing palliative care expected to increase by 51% by 2038 according to a Ministry of Health report from 2016, and services barely keeping up, New Zealanders will be put at risk. This, in the context of the already complicated era of legalised euthanasia, only deepens the divide and false 'choice' it presents.
Read More
Guest Interview: Alex Penk + Professor Roderick MacLeod: The euthanasia debate is far from over
By Guest Contributor, Alex Penk. Alex interviewed an expert, Professor Roderick MacLeod, to make sense of the latest euthanasia statistics and untangle the advocates' claims.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: Swiss doctors back restrictions on assisted suicide
By The Defender. Switzerland, the jurisdiction with the longest-standing legislation allowing for assisted suicide, has in recent years come increasingly under pressure to further liberalise its laws. However, the Swiss Medical Association has clarified its attitude toward assisted suicide – and it is very restrictive.
Read More
NZ Herald: Canadian woman suffering from long Covid applies for assisted suicide
A Canadian woman experiencing ongoing long Covid symptoms more than two years after catching the virus has applied for voluntary euthanasia. Tracey Thompson, a Toronto resident in her 50s, told CTV News she had begun the process of applying for Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD), a procedure that first became legal in Canada in 2016, due to her enduring illness and lack of financial support.
Read More
Sunday Star-Times Editor, Tracy Watkins: "we haven't earned the right to euthanasia"
By Tracy Watkins: The Ministry of Health has six full-time workers dedicated to euthanasia; none dedicated to palliative care. The fear is that it’s not a free choice at all between euthanasia and palliative care when the odds are so heavily stacked against dying patients accessing the sort of palliative care they deserve. This was my fear in 2020 when the euthanasia laws were being debated; that we hadn’t earned the right to euthanasia so long as we continued to do palliative care on the cheap. Clearly nothing has changed since then. If anything, the situation has worsened. Shame on us. We need to do better.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: Canada aims to legalise euthanasia for people with mental illness
By The Defender. In Canada, like New Zealand, the conversation of euthanasia and assisted suicide started by highlighting situations of it being used as a “last resort”. The goalposts have shifted rapidly in Canada. Canada is now on track to expand eligibility for euthanasia to people with mental illness after their expert panel released its final report on the topic recently.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: New study shows suicide increases where euthanasia is legalised
By The Defender. A new peer-reviewed study published in the Journal of Ethics in Mental Health, reveals that current data from European countries shows increases in suicide rates, when compared to suicide rates from countries who do not have assisted suicide or euthanasia available, debunking claims that legalising ‘assisted dying’ would reduce non-assisted suicides.
Read More
The Pulse: "Harrowing": Applications for euthanasia appear to increase 50% month-on-month
By the Pulse. The Pulse host Kate Cormack interviewed Henoch Kloosterboer, spokesperson for #DefendNZ and Editor of The Defender, on the latest news around the topic of assisted suicide and euthanasia in New Zealand, including the recent screening of a biased documentary on TVNZ’s Sunday programme, as well as the dramatic increase in numbers of people seeking and going through with an assisted suicide or euthanasia death.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: Slanted Sunday segment glorifies tragedy
By The Defender. "One woman's brave story..." was the opening statement to TVNZ's Sunday programme advertisement for Esther's Story on May 15. That assertion made it clear from the start what angle the segment would take on Esther Richard's euthanasia stance... What it really should have said was "one woman's tragic story".
Read More
The Spectator: Why is Canada euthanising the poor?
By Yuan Yi Zhu. Since last year, Canadian law, in all its majesty, has allowed both the rich as well as the poor to kill themselves if they are too poor to continue living with dignity. In fact, the ever-generous Canadian state will even pay for their deaths. What it will not do is spend money to allow them to live instead of killing themselves.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: Death-on-demand soars in NZ: 66 die from new assisted suicide and euthanasia law
By The Defender. “There are a number of significant concerns that have already been highlighted in the reporting made available by the Ministry of Health this week. Vulnerable New Zealanders are clearly already being put at risk due to the inferior legislation. We can, and must, do better” says #DefendNZ spokesperson, Henoch Kloosterboer.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: Why did international 'fact checkers' distort truth about euthanasia for COVID in New Zealand?
By The Defender. If you’ve been following #DefendNZ for a while now, you’ll know that late last year we sent an important Official Information Act request (OIA) to the New Zealand Ministry of Health (MOH). What this so-called ‘fact check’ has actually done is to create a misleading sense of ‘nothing-to-see-here’ about the issue of COVID-19 patients and their eligibility for euthanasia in New Zealand.
Read More
BioEdge: Expert wants assisted suicide available for anorexia patients
By Michael Cook. A leading eating disorder specialist has proposed that patients with anorexia nervosa should be allowed access to assisted suicide. However, bioethics writer Wesley J. Smith, writing in the National Review, slated this approach as “abandonment”.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Southland man exceeds life expectancy by 50 years
By Laura Hooper. Southland man Robert Goodwin can vividly recall the day he was wheeled out of surgery at Dunedin hospital and given six months to live. It was a special moment when he realised he had made it 50 years since the prognosis, Goodwin said. “I did have a few too many beers with a couple of mates ... I’m very proud,” he laughed.
Read More
EXCLUSIVE: MOH says Kiwis with COVID-19 can now be eligible for euthanasia
By The Defender. An Official Information Act reply to The Defender, from the Ministry of Health, which says that patients with COVID-19 could be eligible for euthanasia, has left National MP Simon O’Connor disappointed but not surprised. When we put this matter to National MP Simon O’Connor, he expressed concerns about what clearly seems to be an expansion of the new law less than a month after it came into force.
Read More
Bioedge: Euthanasia takes a backward step in Portugal and Colombia
By Michael Cook. The president of Portugal has refused to sign a bill legalising euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. Marcelo Rebelo de Sousa criticised its wording as imprecise. This effectively shelves the euthanasia bill until a new parliament and government are chosen early next year.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: South Canterbury support services make stand on End of Life Act
By Esther Ashby-Coventry. Anyone seeking assisted dying will not be allowed to undertake the procedure on site at Hospice South Canterbury or Highfield LifeCare in Timaru. “We will continue to strive to minimise suffering be it physical, emotional, spiritual, social or psychological. We will also continue to support families and whānau, before and after a patient’s death.”
Read More
Local Matters: Anti-euthanasia campaigner continues fight
By James Addis. An anti-euthanasia activist who fronts the national #DefendNZ campaign says the debate on the End of Life Choice Act (EOLCA) is far from over. Henoch Kloosterboer says since the passing of the Act, advocacy for the vulnerable has become more critical than ever. “Some New Zealanders now wield the state-sanctioned legal power to deliberately end the lives of others, or to assist in their suicides,” he says.
Read More
MercatorNet: Could voluntary assisted dying become contagious?
By Michael Cook. Research shows that the experience of losing a parent through suicide is a risk factor for children. How about assisted suicide and euthanasia? Does assisted dying ( euthanasia and assisted suicide) have a negative impact upon other people? It’s rare for this question to be raised in debates. If it is, supporters dismiss it – it’s my life and it’s none of their business, is their response.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Increased funding for palliative care needed to prevent bad Millennial deaths
By Tom Hunt. Many millennials are forecast to die badly with reports of a palliative care system already struggling on dwindling fundraising and experts saying we already have a “postcode lottery” determining who dies in pain. “It is ironic that the new end-of-life-choice service is fully funded, and our hospice care funded less than 50 per cent.”
Read More
Epoch Times: ‘Death Is Becoming an Industry’: Euthanasia Opponents Bemoan Rise in Medically Assisted Deaths in Canada
By Lee Harding. Recently released statistics and anecdotal accounts have caused anti-euthanasia activists increased concern, as they believe medically assisted death is not only permitted, but encouraged. Medically assisted deaths in Quebec rose to 2,426 in the year ending March 31, an increase of 37 percent over the year before.
Read More
Bioedge: NSW Parliament debates ‘assisted dying’
By Michael Cook. On Friday the Parliament of NSW began its debate on the controversial bill to legalise “voluntary assisted dying”. Premier, Dominic Perrottet said, “A strong society protects and cherishes its most fragile members. This bill at its heart enshrines a new principle—that we can intentionally help terminate the lives of certain people to end their suffering. It turns on its head a bedrock of our ethics—that we help, not hurt; that we offer hope, not harm.”
Read More
The Gisborne Herald: Ending well: fund palliative care also
By Danielle van Dalen. I would never expect my doctor's pay cheque to come from “cakes and op shops”. But for New Zealand's palliative care services, this is the reality. Fundraising is required to cover about half of the costs of Hospice NZ each year. $77m must be fundraised every year to cover the shortfall; much of that coming from op-shops.
Read More
The Defender: One-in-five New Zealanders with disabilities cannot afford to see a GP
By The Defender. 21.5% of disabled adults were not able to visit a GP due to costs, compared to just 12.7% of non-disabled adults. Disabled adults are 2.3 times more likely not to be able to afford a doctor's visit. This alarming inequity echoes what #DefendNZ ambassador Dr Huhana Hickey forewarned before the End of Life Choice Act was passed.
Read More
RTL UK: New Zealand: Euthanasia law comes into effect, campaigners begin “fight back” to protect the vulnerable
By Right To Life News: As New Zealand’s euthanasia legislation comes into effect, anti-euthanasia campaigners have launched an initiative to begin the path towards repealing the legislation and protecting the vulnerable. #DefendNZ has launched a new campaign to “protect” the vulnerable from the new law, and to “expose and improve” the law as it is written.
Read More
Waatea News: Breath of life right to the grave
By Waatea Team. The End of Life Choice Act is now law, but a Taitokerau leader says there’s a lot of talking still needed for Māori to come to terms with the change. She says the process can make family feel left out, and challenges some firmly held tikanga. Dame Naida Glavish says consultation with Māori on the law was minimal compared with the extensive discussion that went on over the legal framework of organ donation.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: More scrutiny needed as assisted dying becomes law
By Dr Sinéad Donnelly, Prof Rod MacLeod MNZM, Dr Richard Egan and Dr Simon Walker. The End of Life Choice Act marks a significant shift in both medical and societal responses to suffering. It will be crucial to pick up whether people are opting for assisted dying (or choosing it earlier than they might otherwise) because of a lack of access to high-quality palliative care.
Read More
Media Release: #DefendNZ relaunches to protect vulnerable New Zealanders from assisted suicide and euthanasia
By The Defender. #DefendNZ has officially relaunched today, in order to fight for the protection of vulnerable New Zealanders against the dangers of the End of Life Choice Act (EOLCA). “Today our nation has undergone one of the most seismic shifts in law, healthcare and medical ethics in its entire history,” says a #DefendNZ spokesperson.
Read More
Local Matters: Hospice refuses to facilitate assisted dying
By James Addis. Harbour Hospice has taken a stand against assisted dying, refusing to allow medication designed to hasten death to be administered at any of its facilities. Harbour Hospice chief executive Jan Nichols says Hospice has taken the position based on the “global philosophy of hospice care”, which is “to neither hasten nor postpone death.”
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: NZ Ministry of Health already considering rewriting NZ euthanasia law
By Thomas Manch. Ministry of Health officials have highlighted “complex and sensitive elements” to the End of Life Choice Act. Among the issues: competing pressures in the health system, possible need to rewrite parts of the law to resolve “legislative issues”, and numerous unresolved questions and risks surrounding assisted dying services.
Read More
Newsroom: GP costs a ‘catastrophic’ failure for disabled Kiwis
By Ben Leonard. About one in five disabled adults cannot afford to visit a GP – hindered by consultation and transport costs. The Government’s planned changes to disability support must address the cost of accessing primary healthcare, the Disability Rights Commissioner says.
Read More
RNZ: Only 10 percent of health workers 'definitely willing' to carry out euthanasia - survey
By Guyon Espiner. More than a 1000 people are expected to request to end their lives in the first year of New Zealand's assisted dying regime. The lack of doctors willing to carry out assisted dying may lead to those doctors who are willing to have to travel the country administering euthanasia if the service is not available in all areas.
Read More
NZ Herald: Distressing death warning for 'unregulated' euthanasia drugs
By Guyon Espiner. Patients requesting euthanasia will be given unapproved, unregulated and "off label" medicines, sparking warnings of prolonged and distressing deaths. People who chose to swallow or ingest the fatal medicines, rather than taking them intravenously, would be given drugs that were compounded (mixed up) by a pharmacist and provided to the patient without being approved by regulator Medsafe.
Read More
RNZ: Euthanasia: What happens if the drugs don't work?
By Guyon Espiner. What happens if a patient doesn't die during a euthanasia attempt? That's one of a number of ethical and legal questions being asked by palliative care experts who say we are woefully unprepared to introduce assisted dying. “Death doesn't necessarily follow within minutes or even hours, it can take a lot longer and well documented cases of stuff not working."
Read More
RNZ: Fears euthanasia training will just be online course
By Guyon Espiner. Palliative care specialists fear health practitioners with as little as six hours online training could end up providing euthanasia for patients who would have wanted to live if they had proper care and pain relief. Their concerns come as a new Ministry of Health survey reveals fewer than a third of health practitioners are prepared to participate in the assisted dying regime.
Read More
Global News: Canadian Senate passes Bill C-7, expanding assisted dying to include mental illness
By Joan Bryden. Intolerably suffering Canadians who are not near the natural end of their lives now have the right to seek medical assistance in dying. But disability rights groups have strenuously opposed the bill, arguing it devalues the lives of people with disabilities, particularly those who are Black, racialized, Indigenous or marginalized.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Med students become more opposed to euthanasia while at uni
By Will Harvie. Medical students become more opposed to euthanasia as they progress through medical school, a new study has found. Almost 65 per cent of second year medical students at Otago University supported euthanasia or assisted dying, compared with 39 per cent in fifth year, the researchers found.
Read More
Otago Daily Times: Concern money used to sway doctors to euthanasia
By Mike Houlahan. An Otago doctor believes the Ministry of Health is trying to use money to entice medical professionals into offering euthanasia services. “I was shocked when, upon answering that I will not take part in assisted dying, the MoH survey offered the following question: ‘What areas would you want more information on for you to be willing to provide assisted dying services?’’”
Read More
RNZ: Doctors prepare to put euthanasia law into action
By Eva Corlett. Doctors are gearing up for a hefty year of planning and preparation with the End of Life Choice Act set to come into force. The New Zealand Medical Association opposed the law, but its chair Dr Kate Baddock said the country had spoken. The law allows doctors to be conscientious objectors of euthanasia.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Where are the safeguards for Māori and the disabled in end of life law?
By Dr Huhana Hickey MNZM. In 12 months assisted dying will be legal as, unsurprisingly, the mainstream demographic has predictably spoken with a 65.2 per cent yes vote in the preliminary results. I remain opposed to this law for two reasons – those being the risk to indigenous people and the disabled, as evidenced by international research in countries where it is legal.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Referendum results: End of Life Choice Act passes, legalising assisted dying
By Hannah Martin. Assisted dying and euthanasia will be legal in New Zealand next year, with the public voting through the End of Life Choice Act. The Electoral Commission released the preliminary results on Friday afternoon. Meanwhile, conservative lobby group Family First has called the result a “sad and dangerous day for the vulnerable”.
Read More
Today Online: Dutch move towards euthanasia for under-12s
The Hauge. The Netherlands moved towards making euthanasia legal for terminally-ill children aged between one and 12 after the coalition government on Tuesday (Oct 13) backed the move. Health minister Hugo de Jonge said he would now draft regulations for the practice, after a study by experts showed some children were suffering "hopelessly".
Read More
The Spinoff: However well-intentioned, the euthanasia law can never be racism-proof
By Dr Hirini Kaa. I’m voting no on the End of Life Choice (EOLC) referendum. I have many concerns about this legislation, including around the technical aspects and operation of the law. But I’m also very concerned about its impact on the vulnerable and marginalised in our society. Here are my top four reasons.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Euthanasia referendum: Lawyer believes End of Life Choice Act could be 'bully’s playground'
By Richard McLeod. Although privileged New Zealanders who become terminally ill may have many other choices available to them, the law will also apply to terminally ill New Zealanders who are vulnerable and weak. For them, the “Your life your choice” mantra rings hollow. There’s no compassion in ending the life of someone who has little or no other choice.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Referendum not about euthanasia, but a specific piece of legislation
By Kevin Campbell. It is of further serious concern is the process by which the End of Life Choice Act has got to a binding referendum, together with the poor understanding among voters of what the referendum is about. It is significant, but shameful, that Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has stated she believed that euthanasia should never have gone to a referendum.
Read More
Newsroom: Assisted dying an opportunity cost
By Dr Ben Gray. The End of Life Choice Act will require significant resources which may only benefit a small number of older, educated white people, argues the University of Otago's Dr Ben Gray. “Changing the status quo now will require focus on this issue and take attention away from the much more serious issues of responding to the Covid-19 pandemic.”
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Euthanasia referendum: How a daughter's view of cancer shaped her view
By Ellen O'Dwyer. In the years he was mobile, Rachel would curl the ball through the goal posts of his walker, practising her winning kicks. Rachel Major shared her love of football with her dad Glenn until she was nine. Glenn died at the age of 42 of a brain tumour, having been diagnosed with cancer before Rachel was born.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Euthanasia referendum: 'The proposed law isn't watertight'
By Grant Illingworth QC. As New Zealanders, we like the idea of having a choice. We also like the idea of showing compassion towards those who are suffering. Rightly so; but the assisted dying referendum does not involve voting about an idea; it concerns a set of rules that have already been drafted and enacted by Parliament. Those rules will come into force automatically if a majority vote in favour of them.
Read More
RNZ: Referendum campaigners relieved at election delay
By Alex Perrottet. Most campaigners over the two referendums in this year's election are breathing a sigh of relief that voting day has been delayed another month, giving them time to change more minds. The two referendum topics have been subject to much debate this year, but for those most involved in the campaigning it's clearly not enough.
Read More
Newshub: Euthanasia referendum: Terminal cancer patient reveals why she's against legalising assisted dying
By Patrick Gower. Vicki Walsh was told in June 2011 her brain cancer diagnosis was terminal and she only had 12 to 14 months to live. However, now aged 53, Walsh has had nine more years of life since. She says that might not have happened if the choice of assisted dying had been available and will vote against legalising euthanasia in the referendum.
Read More
Newsroom: No room for error on assisted dying
By Caralise Trayes. Most Kiwis aren't aware that the end of life choice act is not a concept they'll be voting for, but specific, unmovable legislation. And if we make a mistake, death is a heavy penalty, writes Caralise Trayes.
Read More
AP News: Dutch euthanasia center sees 22% rise in requests in 2019
By Mike Corder. A Dutch organization that carries out euthanasia received 3,122 requests last year, a 22% increase from the year before, the Euthanasia Expertise Center said Friday. “Every work day, 13 people say: ‘Help me, I can’t go on,’” Steven Pleiter, director of the center formerly known as the End of Life Clinic, said.
Read More
RNZ: End of Life Choice Bill on euthanasia goes to referendum
By Jo Moir. New Zealanders now have the casting vote on whether to make euthanasia legal. Last night Parliament voted 69 votes to 51 in favour of the End of Life Choice Bill that proposes to make assisted dying legal for some terminally ill people. After New Zealand First secured a change three weeks ago to ensure the decision would be sent to a referendum, it will not be known whether the bill becomes law until next year.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: MPs vote in favour of End of Life Choice Bill at final reading
By Henry Cooke. MPs have casted their final votes on the End of Life Choice Bill. That bill would set in motion a public vote on legalised euthanasia. "The most liberal Parliament in New Zealand's history has voted through this dangerous and permissive bill. Now the only hope of stopping euthanasia being legalised is through a referendum at the election," Maggie Barry said.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Euthanasia bill passes second reading
By Henry Cooke. David Seymour's End of Life Choice bill has passed its second reading 70-50 and is taking legal assisted dying one step closer to becoming law. Labour and National MPs voted with their conscience on the issue, while Green and NZ First MPs all voted in support. "We cannot risk one wrong death. This bill cannot guarantee that will not happen," Agnes Loheni said.
Read More
Scoop: We need to talk about suicide and euthanasia
By Jannah Dennison. It is extraordinarily difficult to discuss suicide and euthanasia at the same time. But there is an urgent conversation to be had: what are the implications for New Zealand’s suicide prevention programme of introducing the End of Life Choice Bill?
Read More
Scoop: Muslim Community: We ask the PM and MPs to oppose euthanasia
Dr Mustafa Farouk QSM: FIANZ, the voice of New Zealand’s Muslim community since 1979, is opposed to euthanasia and the End of Life Choice Bill. We give voice to our concerns on behalf of our community. As New Zealand Muslims, we are worried that the vulnerability of our community members could be exploited if euthanasia is legalised by Parliament.
Read More
NZ Disability Commissioner’s Canada euthanasia concerns confirmed in UN report
Media Release: Disability Commissioner Paula Tesoriero outlayed her concerns about the End of Life Choice Bill. "I'm concerned that the safeguards are woefully inadequate,” she said. “I'm deeply troubled by the fact that this conversation is taking place in the absence of having a wider discussion about adequate disability support services in New Zealand.”
Read More
RNZ Checkpoint: 14 experts weigh in as 23 MPs still undecided on euthanasia vote
By Alex Perrottet. Checkpoint has run the numbers and canvassed experts views from around the country and overseas. Interviewees include Dr Otmar Kloiber - Secretary General of the World Medical Association, Robert Preston, Prof Margaret Somerville, Kate Baddock, Dr Rod MacLeod from Auckland's Hibiscus Hospice, Dr Sinead Donnelly and many more.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: The euthanasia debate: Death is not a black-and-white issue
By Dr Amanda Landers. I get the feeling the general public think death is a black-and-white issue. I cannot think of a subject that has more grey. The answer to bad deaths is not euthanasia. The answer is a better understanding of basic medical ethics, of palliative medicine, of what happens to the body when it is dying, and how to care for someone at the end of life.
Read More
TVNZ 1 NEWS: Doctors oppose Euthanasia Bill: 'We didn't train to end someone's life'
By Cushla Norman. Doctors against the Euthanasia Bill have stepped up their campaign, taking out a full-page advert in today's Herald on Sunday with more than a thousand signatures in opposition. A letter of opposition was organised by Dr Sinead Donnelley as thoughts on assisted dying continues to divide the public, politicians and medical professionals.
Read More
NZ Herald: Hundreds of proposed amendments could push euthanasia bill well into next year
By Derek Cheng. MPs opposing a bill that would legalise euthanasia are planning to put up more than 100 amendments that could push its possible passage well into next year. As currently drafted, the bill would allow New Zealanders to request assisted dying if they have a terminal illness or suffer from "a grievous and irremediable medical condition".
Read More
RNZ: 1000 Doctors sign letter against 'assisted suicide' Bill
More than 1000 doctors have signed an open letter saying they want no part in what they call assisted suicide. Dr Sinead Donnelly, who organised the letter, said the bill is unworkable, “The message is that as doctors we don't want to be part of it. You're going to, in our view, destroy the profession of medicine by drawing us in to ending the life of our patients.”
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: Euthanasia bill would be rife for exploitation by the selfish and the abusive, says QC
By Grant Illingworth QC. The End of Life Choice Bill may be compelling in its rationale, but the execution of such a law would break the social contract the State has with some of our weakest and most vulnerable citizens and expose them to a dangerous new world in which manipulation and coercion could take on deadly consequences.
Read More
Newshub: 'We need politicians to protect us': Terminal patient slams euthanasia Bill
By Simon Shepherd & Finn Hogan. Speaking to Newshub Nation, Vicki Walsh sent a plea to politicians to oppose the Bill. “We need them to protect us from this bill because idealistically, it could look very appealing to some people. It’s what it opens up.”
Read More
Age Concern expert says euthanasia may devalue the lives of older people
Media Release: 10% of older people in New Zealand experience some form of abuse, according to Age Concern professional educator on elder abuse and neglect, Hanny Naus. Age Concern see a wide range of older people who are abused, with 4 out of 5 of them being abused by family members.
Read More
TVNZ 1 NEWS: Kiwi man sentenced to 8-year suspended jail for assisted suicides of three disabled people in South Africa
The 58-year-old Kiwi euthanasia advocate who appeared in a Dunedin court in 2011 charged with attempting to murder his terminally ill mother in 2006, has now pleaded guilty to three cases of assisted suicide in South Africa. He faced charges of premedited murder at the Western Cape High Court. Renée Joubert of Euthanasia-Free NZ applauded the decision today.
Read More
Magic Talk: #DefendNZ Bioethics Professor outlines key ethical flaws with euthanasia in exclusive interview
Magic Drive with Ryan Bridge: Ryan Bridge speaks with a euthanasia expert, Professor of Bioethics, Margaret Somerville. “What we're doing here is legalising intentional killing. Now up until you've got some legislation that allows that, as you just have in Victoria, that is first degree murder! So we have to look at what happens with this – it gets normalised.”
Read More
Australian professor condemns Kiwi euthanasia bill in new #DefendNZ videos being released
Media Release: Videos featuring experts will today be released on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. Experts to feature include Australian Bioethics Professor Margaret Somerville. She sees the proposed legalisation of euthanasia as “the crossing of an ethical and legal Rubicon, after which it becomes impossible to contain the application and practice of euthanasia.”
Read More
RNZ: Lord Alex Carlile: Why he supports NZ lawyers against the End of Life Choice Bill – with Jim Mora
Jim Mora interviews the UK’s Lord Carlile of Berriew QC. He has been involved in parliamentary activity in the UK for several years now, opposing euthanasia bills that have been presented, due to concerns over various safeguards. He explains why he opposes New Zealand's End of Life Choice Bill from a "secular, ethical dimension".
Read More
NZLifeNZ.com: 我曾去瑞士寻求安乐死,后来……一名瘫痪女子和中风父亲的故事
克莱尔17岁时因为车祸成为了四肢瘫痪者,她甚至安排自己去瑞士实施安乐死。想一想你可能与父母进行的最艰难的对话!一名新西兰女子,克莱尔·弗里曼 和她的爸爸,在不同的时间段,争论过是否要对自己着手实施安乐死。
Read More
Disability Rights Commissioner says limiting euthanasia Bill to terminally ill won’t protect disabled people
#DefendNZ Media Release. Disability Rights Commissioner Paula Tesoriero MNZM was quoted on TVNZ’s Sunday programme last night speaking against the effectiveness of proposed changes to the End of Life Choice Bill to limit access to euthanasia or assisted suicide to those with terminal illness and with six months left to live. The Bill’s sponsor has suggested this will fix the Bill.
Read More
Newsroom: Why I changed my mind on euthanasia
By Chris Ford. Chris Ford, a former Green Party List MP Candidate, and current Green Party member explains from 'a socialist, progressive and disability rights perspective’ why he has now swung his support to the anti-euthanasia camp', now firmly in the 'no' side on the voluntary euthanasia legislation conversation.
Read More
TVNZ 1 NEWS: Disabled after car crash and previously suicidal, woman now opposes euthanasia law change
By Janet McIntyre. Think about the most difficult conversation you could have with your parents. Claire Freeman is having it right now with her dad and our cameras are rolling. Claire is in a wheel chair after becoming a tetraplegic when she was 17. She’s made numerous attempts on her life and even made arrangements to go to Switzerland to be assisted to die.
Read More
Breakfast TVNZ: Euthanasia bill 'goes against the ethics of our profession' – Medical Association chair says
Hayley Holt interviews Dr Kate Baddock. Newly proposed amendments to the End of Life Choice Bill, which is set to have its Second Reading in Parliament, have been strongly rejected by the New Zealand Medical Association, with its chair saying it "goes against the ethics of our profession".
Read More
Voxy: New poll reveals unease with euthanasia legislation
Most New Zealanders don’t support euthanasia for those who refuse treatment. A new nationwide Curia Market Research poll has found that 60% of New Zealanders don’t want a law that would allow an 18-year-old to refuse treatment and instead choose to die by euthanasia. A quarter (24%) would support such a law.
Read More
Dominion Post: Doctors want no part in assisted suicide full page advert
We endorse the views of the World Medical Association and the New Zealand Medical Association that physician assisted suicide an euthanasia are unethical, even if they were made legal. Doctors are not necessary in the regulation of practice of assisted suicide. They are included only to provide a cloak of medical legitimacy.
Read More
#DefendNZ representatives arrive in Wellington to advocate for vulnerable ahead of possible Second Reading of End of Life Choice Bill on 22 May
#DefendNZ Media Release. We all have a stake in the End of Life Choice Bill conversation, but for some people, this Bill is more than a thought experiment – it is a clear and present danger. For this reason, some of the people featured in the #DefendNZ documentaries are in the Capital to make themselves available to speak personally with MPs and media.
Read More
TVNZ Sunday: "I'm just going to fight." Claire Freeman speaks on TVNZ's Sunday promo
By Janet McIntyre. TVNZ's Sunday showed this trailer on Sunday 19 May, about how life in a wheelchair drove Claire Freeman to try to end her life, but Claire's now fighting to save other people's lives. "I know of people who will die because of this Bill." The full story will be aired on TVNZ's Sunday programme at 7:30pm on TVNZ One on Sunday 26th May 2019.
Read More
Scoop: New poll shows less support for euthanasia
Euthanasia-Free NZ. A new nationwide Curia Market Research poll shows the gap between supporters and opponents of euthanasia is narrowing, and that many people withdraw their support when asked to consider some of the details involved in the End of Life Choice Bill, says Euthanasia-Free NZ executive officer Renée Joubert.
Read More
NZ Herald Canvas: What is it like to die? A doctor explains.
By Kim Knight. Euthanasia, says MacLeod, is "predominantly a white middle-class push. "There's no push in India for euthanasia, no push in Thailand or Japan. They think we're mad. They look after the people who are most vulnerable. "If we're serious about caring for New Zealanders then we need to make sure that everybody has access to palliative care.”
Read More
TVNZ Te Karere: End of Life Choice bill against tikanga Māori
By Eruera Rerekura. A Māori opponent of the End of Life Choice Bill says the proposed legislation goes against tikanga Māori and the Treaty of Waitangi. Ngapuhi woman Claire Freeman was amongst those who presented her views to parliament this week. The bill was due for its second reading but has been delayed until later this month (likely Wednesday 22 May 2019).
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: End of life choices: The Crown's duty of protection – by Queen's Counsel Grant Illingworth
By Grant Illingworth QC. Opening the door to assisted suicide, without an absolute assurance that mistakes will never be made, would egregiously breach the fundamental obligations of the government. No-one can give such assurance: it is certainly not provided by the bill currently before the House.
Read More
NZ Herald: Anti-euthanasia campaigners spend afternoon at Parliament
By Lucy Bennett: People with disabilities and terminal illnesses spent the afternoon at Parliament today in a last-ditch bid to convince MPs to vote against the End of Life Choice Bill. The controversial Bill, in the name of Act leader David Seymour, is due to have its second reading soon. It passed its first reading 76 votes to 44, by conscience vote.
Read More
End of Life Choice Bill has no place in New Zealand says new book from #DefendNZ
#DefendNZ Media Release. The grassroots movement today releases its book ‘Vote “No” to Assisted Suicide’, which has also been delivered to MPs. It presents a collection of writings illustrating #DefendNZ’s reasons for speaking out against the End of Life Choice Bill, including stories of Kiwis who could be eligible for assisted suicide under the Bill.
Read More
Stuff.co.nz: As a tetraplegic I once supported assisted suicide - but I was wrong
By Claire Freeman. The End of Life Choice Bill comes with a dark side that we cannot ignore, writes Claire Freeman. “For most of my life I've been pro assisted suicide. It was about choice, dignity, and compassion. But it's not a choice for us when we aren't treated equally, in society or within the healthcare system. It isn't a choice when we feel there are no other options.”
Read More
#DefendNZ releases Top 5 Reasons for MPs to Vote ‘NO’ – The End of life Choice Bill will never be safe
#DefendNZ Media Release. The grassroots movement opposed to the End of Life Choice Bill – has listed their Top 5 Reasons why MPs should vote “no” at its Second Reading. The End of Life Choice Bill, should it pass, would put vulnerable people in danger of being coerced into requesting death.
Read More
Scoop: Doctors’ Open Letter Gets 1,000th Signature
Care Alliance: The ‘Doctors Say No’ Open Letter opposing euthanasia has received its 1,000th signature. Organiser Dr Sinead Donnelly, a Wellington-based Palliative Medicine specialist, says she is humbled by the response. “We started with just a very simple one-page website and it has snowballed through word of mouth and social media.”
Read More
NZME Health Central: Watch the full debate - Bill English, David Seymour, Dr Leonie Herx, Claire Freeman talk End of Life Choice Bill in the ChalkTalks panel
Watch the full-length Health Central ChalkTalks panel debate on the End of Life Choice Bill from the ticketed and sold-out event on Wednesday 3 April 2019. Panelists included Former Prime Minister Sir Bill English, Dr Leonie Herx, Claire Freeman, David Seymour, Kerri Nuku of NZNO, and euthanasia advocate Dr Jack Havill.
Read More
Dominion Post: End of Life Choice Bill report offers only ambiguity for MPs before second reading
By Alex Penk. After months of thought and argument, the justice select committee has thrown the End of Life Choice Bill back in Parliament's lap. We're in the strange situation where no-one, not even sponsor David Seymour, is supporting the Bill as it is. The select committee couldn't agree that the bill should pass and made only technical changes to it.
Read More
RNZ: Euthanasia Bill 'loopholes' mean 16-year-olds could apply without parents knowledge: Lawyers, academics say
Morning Report: An open letter calling for greater scrutiny to tidy up unacceptable loopholes in the End of Life Choice Bill has been signed by 75 lawyers and academics. Grant Illingworth QC, told Morning Report he was concerned by a loophole in the bill that could mean 16-year-olds could apply for assisted dying without their parents' knowledge.
Read More
RNZ: Youth worker worried about euthanasia Bill's impact on suicide
By Emma Hatton. Dion Howard, a therapist who specialises in youth suicide is concerned not enough is known about how assisted dying may affect vulnerable youth. He said some coverage of the Bill had glorified assisted dying, "I've had instances of young people quoting methods on how to take your own life, which became a part of our risk assessments of their situations."
Read More